$BDL?.%m%0(B
$B9q8xN)Bg3XDL?.(B 2003.06.16($B7n(B)

--[kd 03-06-16 $BL\[1] 6/16 $B!V9qN)Bg3XK!?MK!0F$HBg3X$NL$Mh$r9M$($k9q2qFb=82q!W<0[2] 5/07 $B=05D1!J8It2J3X0Q0w2q$K$*$1$kEDCf9-0t;a$N0U8+(B
[3] 6/12 $B=54V?7D,!']/0f$h$7$3!VBg3XK!?M2=$NJr$l$?9q2qEzJ[!W(B
----------------------------------------------------------------

----------------------------------------------------------------------
[1] 6/16 $B!V9qN)Bg3XK!?MK!0F$HBg3X$NL$Mh$r9M$($k9q2qFb=82q!W<0l=j!';25D1!5D0w2q4[Bh0l2q5D<<(B

$B!!8F$S$+$1?M!!]/0f$h$7$3!J%8%c!<%J%j%9%H!K(B
            $B!!2CF#=(.NS@5I'!JEl5~Bg3X65O@2H!K(B

$B!!%W%m%0%i%`(B

  $BBh0lIt(B(12:30$B!A(B14:00)
$B!!(B1. $B;J2q[2] 5/7 $B=05D1!J8It2J3X0Q0w2q$K$*$1$kEDCf9-0t;a$N0U8+(B
http://www.shugiin.go.jp/itdb_kaigiroku.nsf/html/kaigiroku/009615620030507011.htm
----------------------------------------------------------------------

$B!{EDCf;29M?M!!8f>R2p$$$?$@$-$^$7$?EDCf$G$4$6$$$^$9!#(B

$B!!;d$O!"J?@.6eG/0l7n$KJ9q(B
$BN)Bg3XEy$NFHN)9T@/K!?M2=$K4X$9$kD4::8!F$2q5D$N%a%s%P!<$H$$$?$7$^$7$F!"(B
$B9qN)Bg3X$NFHK!2=LdBj$K?<$/$+$+$o$C$F$^$$$j$^$7$?!#(B

$B!!K\F|$O0l3XEL$H$7$F0U8+$r?=$7>e$2$?$$$HB8$8$^$9$,!";~4V$N4X78$b$"$j$^(B
$B$7$F!"FbMF$r=q$$$F$^$$$j$^$7$?$N$G!"FI$_>e$2$5$;$F$$$?$@$-$?$$$H;W$$$^(B
$B$9!#$*H$7$J$,$i$*J9$-$$$?$@$/$H$"$j(B
$B$,$?$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B!!8=:_9q2q$G?35D$5$l$F$$$^$99qN)Bg3XK!?MK!0F$K$O?<9o$JL7=b$,4v$D$+4^$^(B
$B$l$F$*$j!"0U$KH?$7$F!"0U?^$9$kL\E*$H$O@5H?BP$N7k2L$r@8$8$k$N$G$O$J$$$+(B
$B$H;W$o$l$^$9!#(B

$B!!0J2e$N:[NL$O3HBg$$$?$7$^(B
$B$9$,!"Bg3X$NK\Mh$NG$L3$G$"$k650i8&5f$N<+MhBg3X$,0l(B
$BBN$H$J$C$F;}$C$F$$$?4k2h!"N)0F!"e!"4k2h!"N)0F$O(B
$BJ82J>J$N8"8B$K0\$5$l$^$7$F!"Bg3X$K$OJ$K$O!"Bg3X$,2A$HM=;;G[J,$dBg(B
$B3X$N2~GQ$r7hDj$9$k8"8B$^$G$bM?$($i$l$F$$$^$9!#$7$?$,$C$F!"$3$N@)EY$O!"(B
$B@/I\$d41N=$,!"6/NO$J8"8B$r;}$A!"9qN)Bg3X$rD>@\E}@)$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k;EAH(B
$B$_$rFbJq$7$F$$$k$H8@$&$3$H$,$G$-$k$N$G$"$j$^$9!#(B

$B!!6qBNE*$K8+$^$9$H!"J82J>J$O9qN)Bg3X$KBP$7!"O;G/4V$N650i8&5fEy$NL\I8!"(B
$B7W2h$r;X<(!"G'2D$$$?$7$^$9!#$=$7$F!"O;G/8e$N@.@SI>2A!"$3$l$OC#@.EYI>2A(B
$B$G$4$6$$$^$9$,!"$HM=;;G[J,!"$=$l$+$iJ$N;X<(!"I>(B
$B2A!"M=;;G[J,Ey$K=>$C$F650i!"8&5f!"1?1DEy$rMh!"!VJ8It>J$O!"$=$N8"8B$N9T;H$KEv$D(B
$B$F!"K!N'!J$3$l$K4p$/L?Na$r4^$`!#!K$KJLCJ$NDj$,$"$k>l9g$r=|$$$F$O!"9T@/(B
$B>e5Z$S1?1D>e$N4FFD$r9T$o$J$$$b$N$H$9$k!#!WJ8It>J@_CVK!BhO;>rFs9`!"$H$5(B
$B$l$F$-$?$N$G$"$j$^$9!#$7$?$,$C$F!"$3$N@)EY$O!"Bg3X$KBP$9$k5,@)6/2=$r0U(B
$BL#$7$F$*$j$^$7$F!"9=B$2~3W$N4z0u$G$"$k5,@)4KOB$HL@$i$+$KL7=b$9$k$b$N$G(B
$B$"$j$^$9!#(B

$B!!$^$?!"Bg3XK\Mh$N3XLdE*;HL?$KBP$9$k0J>e$N$h$&$JOD6J$O!"@$3&$KNc$r8+$J(B
$B$$$b$N$G$b$"$j$^$9!#$3$l$O$^$?!"7{K!Fs==;0>r$N3XLd$N<+M3$NJ]>c$d650i4p(B
$BK\K!==>r$N650i$NITEv$J;YG[$NGS=|$KH?$9$k$3$H$O!"4{$KB?$/$N<1l$G650i8&5f$K=>;v$7$F$*$l$P!"$3$N;EAH$_$,Bg3X$KE,9g$7$J$$$3(B
$B$H$OMF0W$KM}2r$G$-$k$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B!!$^$:!"650i$K$D$$$F8+$^$9$H!"$=$NL\E*$O!"3X@88D?M$NG=NO$r?-$P$7!"?M@8(B
$BES>e$G$N:$Fq$K:]$7AOB$E*$K<+8J$r7A@.$9$kG=NO$rM\@.$9$k$3$H$K$"$k$H;W$$(B
$B$^$9!#3X@8$OC1$KCN<1$r=,F@$9$k$@$1$G$O$J$/$F!"<+J,$NF,G>$G9M$($k$3$H$r(B
$B3X$P$J$1$l$P$J$j$^$;$s!#$^$?!"$5$^$6$^$J5!2q$r$H$i$($F?M3J$N7A@.$r?^$k(B
$B$3$H$bI,MW$G$"$j$^$9!#?M4V$NK\$C$F7W2h$rN)$F$k$3$H$d!"FC$K?tCM2=$9$k$3$H$OE~DlIT2DG=(B
$B$G$"$j$^$7$F!"$b$7$=$l$,6/MW$5$l$k$J$i$P!"650i$NK\^^$C$F8&5f$r9T$&$3(B
$B$H$O!"L50UL#$G$"$k$H8@$o$6$k$rF@$^$;$s!#$b$7$3$N@)EY$,h$j$N9q!"$3$l$O%5%C%A%c!<$,8@$C$?$o$1$G(B
$B$9$,!"$+$iC&$9$k$3$H$O$G$-$J$$$G$7$g$&!#D9$$L\$G8+$?>l9g!"9q:]6%AhNO$O(B
$B$`$7$mDc2<$9$k$N$G$O$J$$$+$H4mW|$5$l$^$9!#(B

$B!!$$$:$l$K$$$?$7$^$7$F$b!"K\@)EY$N$b$H$G$O!"??$N650i8&5f$r9T$&$3$H$O:$(B
$BFq$G$"$j!"$b$7$=$l$,6/MW$5$l$k$J$i$P!"650i8&5f$NK\57$J$/$5$l$k$3$H$OL@$i$+$G$"$j$^$9!#$3$N$3$H$O!"J8It(B
$BBg?C$NEv=i$NH?BP@e!"9T3W$H$7(B
$B$F$N0UL#$b;}$?$J$1$l$P$J$j$^$;$s!#9T3W$NL\E*$O%9%j%`2=!"8zN(2=$G$"$j$^(B
$B$7$?!#$7$?$,$C$F!"@/I\$N6HL3$b8"8B$b=L>.$5$l$M$P$J$i$J$$$O$:$G$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B$H$3$m$,!"$5$-$K=R$Y$?%5%$%/%k$K$*$1$k3F6HL3!":vDj!"G'2D!"I>2A!"::Dj$O!"(B
$B?7$7$/H/@8$7$?KDBg$GHQ`t$J;vL3NL$r4^$_!"$7$+$b!"$=$l$i$O$9$Y$F@/I\$N$b(B
$B$H$K=8Cf2=$5$l$F$$$^$9!#$7$?$,$C$F!"$=$N6HL3$b8"8B$b8=:_$h$j$bA}Bg!"6/(B
$B2=$5$l$k$3$H$K$J$j$^$9!#>/$J$/$H$b=L>.$5$l$k$3$H$O:$Fq$G$"$j$^$9!#(B

$B!!$3$NL7=b$O!"3FBg3X$K$*$$$F$b$"$i$o$l$^$9!#$5$-$K=R$Y$?2~3W%5%$%/%k$K(B
$B$*$$$F!"Cf4|7W2h$N:n@.!"G/EY7W2h$N8xI=!"3F2A=qN`$N:n@.$H$d$j$H$j!"(B
$B:bL3=tI=$NDs=P!"7h;;Js9p=q$NDs=PEy!"3FBg3X$G$bKDBg$GHQ`t$J;vL3NL$,H/@8(B
$B$7!"$=$l$K1~$8$FB?$/$N?M0w$H:b8;$,650i8&5f0J30$N6HL3$KHq$d$5$l$k$3$H$K(B
$B$J$j$^$9!#$=$l$K$bA}$7$F!"?7$7$/FsL>$N4F;v!"B??t$NLr0w!"3X30;v$7$F$$$k?M!9(B
$B$KBP$7$F$OI,MW$G$O$J$/!"H]!"$`$7$mLBOG$GM-32$G$9$i$"$k$N$KBP$7$F!"$=$&(B
$B$G$J$$?M!9$KBP$7$F$N$_B?>/M-8z$K5!G=$9$k$H$$$&5U@b$,$"$k$+$i$G$9!#$=$l(B
$B$O!"F|K\$NBg3X$N:GDc?e=`$r0z$->e$2$k$N$K$OLrN)$D$+$b$7$l$^$;$s$,!"5U$K(B
$B:G9b?e=`$r2!$72<$2!"A4BN$H$7$F$b?e=`$rDc2<$5$;$k2DG=@-$,6K$a$F9b$$$H9M(B
$B$($i$l$^$9!#(B

$B!!$J$<$J$i!"$=$l$O650i8&5f$N30LLE*I>2A!"FC$K$=$N?tCM2=$HAj$^$C$F!"G.?4(B
$B$GM-G=$J?M!9$N3XLdE*FbH/@-$r$=$.!"?M4V@:?@$N=c?h$JAOB$E*!"H/8+E*%(%M%k(B
$B%.!<$rYxMp$7!"Dc2<$5$;$k$+$i$G$"$j$^$9!#%$%.%j%9$NBg3X$O4{$K$=$l$K$h$k(B
$BB??t$NF,G>N.=P$r7P83$7$?$N$G$9!#6%Ah86M}$K$h$k3h@-2=$O!"0l;~E*$J8z2L$r(B
$B@8$`$+$b$7$l$^$;$s$,!"$?$A$^$AB)@Z$l$7!"A4BN$H$7$FF|K\$N9bEy650i$rK^MG(B
$B$J?e=`$K<}$l$s!"DdBZ$5$;$k$H;W$o$l$^$9!#CfD94|E*$K$O!"0U?^$7$?3h@-2=$G(B
$B$O$J$/!"DdBZ$,7k2L$H$7$F@8$:$k$3$H$K$J$j$^$9!#F|K\$N4k6H$N4v$D$+$N7P83(B
$B$O$=$l$r0E<($7$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B!!;MHVL\!"9T3W$K$OFs$D$Nl6%Ah86M}F3F~$G$"$j!"B>(B
$B$OCOJ}J,8"$G$"$j$^$9!#A0ZL@$7(B
$B$F$*$j$^$9$,!"COJ}$N9qN)Bg3X$HCO0hl6%Ah86M}$N$_$G$O!"4k6HN)CO$Np$d8)L1=jF@$N(B
$B3J:9!"$5$i$K4{$KB8:_$9$kBgI}$JBg3X4V3J:9Ey$K>H$i$7$F!"$5$-$K?($l$?Bg3X(B
$B7P1D$N<+M3$OCOJ}$G$O7$-!"A4BN$H$7$FF|K\$N9qNO$NCOHWD@2<$r>7$/$3$H$O$[$\3Nl$HA4LLE*!":,K\E*$K7k$S$D$1$k$3$H$K(B
$B$h$C$F!"N>$N5pBg$J7P:QE*!"e=R$Y$^$7$?$h$&$K!"K\K!0F$OB?$/$NCWL?E*$JL7=b$rFbJq$7$F$$$^$9$N$G!"(B
$B2f$,9q$N9bEy650i5Z$S3X=Q8&5f$N?e=`$N8~>e$H6Q9U$"$kH/E8$r?^$k$H$$$&L\E*(B
$B$H$OH?BP$N7k2L$r@8$`$3$H$K$J$k$H;W$o$l$k$N$G$"$j$^$9!#2f$,9q$NL$Mh$r8+(B
$B?x$($?M}@-$"$kH=CG$r4|BT$$$?$7$^$9!#(B
----------------------------------------------------------------------

----------------------------------------------------------------------
[3] 6/12$B=54V?7D,!']/0f$h$7$3!VBg3XK!?M2=$NJr$l$?9q2qEzJ[!W(B
----------------------------------------------------------------------
$BO":\%3%i%`(B $BBh#7#12s(B $B]/0f$h$7$3(B $BF|K\$N%k%M%C%5%s%9(B

	   $B"#(B $B"#(B $BBg3XK!?M2=$NJr$l$?9q2qEzJ[(B $B"#(B $B"#(B

  $B!V$3$NK!0F$O!"0l8@$G?=$7>e$2$^$9$H!"MSF,6iFy!"499|C%B[K!0F(B
$B$G$"$j$^$9!W!V2P;v>lE%K@$H?=$7>e$2$F$b$$$$!#qY$7F$$A$H?=$7>e(B
$B$2$F$b$$$$$H;W$$$^$9!W(B

  $BL1lE%K@$7$F2?$+$d$k$H$$$&$h$&$JN`$G$O$4$6$$$^$;$s!#$I(B
$B$&$>C$7$F$$$?$@$-$?$$!W(B

  $B$3$l$O(B5$B7n(B29$BF|!";21!J8652J3X0Q0w2q$G$N1~=7$G$"$k!#9qN)Bg3X(B
$BK!?MK!0F$O!"$"$C$H$$$&4V$K=05D1!$rDL2a$7!":#!";25D1!$G?35DCf(B
$B$@!#1s;3Bg?C$O9qN)Bg3XK!?M2=$r!"!VF|K\$N3X@)EY$NBgE>49E@$K$J(B
$B$kBgJQ=EMW$J$b$N!W$H0LCV$E$1!"6/9E$JCf1{FMGK$N;Q@*$rJx$7$F$O(B
$B$$$J$$!#1s;3Bg?C$,K!?M2=$N0UL#$r8l$C$?!#(B

  $B!V=t5,@)$r4KOB$7$F!"9qN)Bg3X$,$h$jBg$-$J<+e$KAO0U9)IW$r=E$M!"650i8&5f$N9bEY2=0?(B
$B$$$O8D@-K-$+$JBg3X:n$j$r2DG=$K$9$k$?$a$NK!?M2=$G$"$j$^$9!W(B

  $BBg3XK!?M2=$N5DO@$NNr;K$r8l$jB3$1$?1s;3Bg?C$O!V;d$,?4$r?T$/(B
$B$7$FEzJ[!W$7$?$3$H$N??0U$r<`$_lE%K@H/8@$@$C$?$N$@!#(B
$B1s;3;a$,935D$7$?$h$&$K!"NI<1$NI\$G$"$k$O$:$N;25D1!$K$O!"0?$$(B
$B$OAj1~$7$/$J$$I=8=$+$b$7$l$J$$!#$@$,!"$b$7$=$&$J$i!"1s;3;a$N(B
$B8mKb2=$7H/8@$O!"$b$C$HAj1~$7$/$J$$!#(B

  $B9qN)Bg3XK!?MK!0F$N$I$3$r$I$&FI$a$P!"1s;3EzJ[$K$"$k9qN)Bg3X(B
$B$N<+r$G$"$k!#Bh(B30$B>r$NCf4|L\I8$NI.F,$K!"(B
$B650i8&5f$K4X$9$k;v9`$,5s$2$i$l$F$$$k!#$3$NE@$K$D$$$F$9$G$KBg(B
$B3X4X78j2pF~$K@x(B
$B$`3XLd$N4m5!!Y!K!#(B

  $BAa0pEDBg3X65J!"J8It2J3XBg?C$H$O!"0lBN$I$s$Je$,4^$^$l$F$$$k$3$H$NLdBjE@$r7+$jJV$7-Mh$K$o$?$C$F5-O?$K;D$7$F$*$$$F$$$?$@$-$?$$!W(B

  $BNkLZ425D0w$,$9$+$5$:H?O@$7$?!#!Ve$2$F$$$k$s$G$9$h!#K!N'$r(B
$B:n$k$H$$$&$3$H$O$=$&$$$&$3$H$G$9$h!#L$Mh1J9e!"$3$N>rJ8$r$=$N(B
$B;~!9$NEv;vH$7$^$9!#$=$NK!J8$K$jCi$;$P$$$$$N$G$9!W(B

  $BNkLZ5D0w$N8@$&DL$j$G$"$k!#K!N'>e$OJ82JBg?C$,Bg3X$N8&5f$NCf(B
$B4|L\I8$rDj$a$k$H=q$$$F$*$-$J$,$i!"!V-Mh$K$o$?$C$F5-O?$K;D!W$9$N$@$+$i?4G[L5MQ$H8@$&EzJ[(B
$B$r!"0lBNC/$,?.MQ$G$-$k$N$@$m$&$+!#(B

		 $B"#(B $B41N=$,650i$r6t$$DY$9(B $B"#(B

  $B;d$?$A$O$D$$!"(B1$BG/A0$N$3$H$rA[$$=P$9I,MW$,$"$k!#=;4p%M%C%H(B
$B$NF3F~$K$O!V8D?M>pJs$NJ]8n$KK|A4$r4|$9$k$?$a!"B.$d$+$K!"=jMW(B
$B$NAr7o$,!"8N>.^<7C;0.^<r(B
$B$N)"$H$$$&K!N'$KDj$a$i$l$J$,$i!"$3$N9q$N@/I\$H41N=$?$A$O$$$H(B
$B$b4JC1!"$+$D!"40A4$K$3$NK!N'$rL5;k$7$?!#$=$N$3$H$r;W$($Q!"0l(B
$B3UN=$NEzJ[$,G!2?$[$I$N3NLs$H$J$jF@$k$N$+$HLd$o$6$k$rF@$J$$!#(B
$B1s;3Bg?C$N!VJ$N0U(B
$B?^$,8+$(8+$($G$"$k!#$?$H$($PM};v$N?t$G$"$k!#Bg3X1?1D$N9`E@$K(B
$BN)$D$N$,Lr0w2q$G$"$k!#Lr0w2q$O3XD9$H4F;v(B2$BL>5Z$SM};v$K$h$C$F(B
$B9=@.$5$l$k!#3XD9$H4F;v(B2$BL>$OJ82JBg?C$,G$L?$7!"M};v$N?t$OBg3X(B
$BKh$K$J$s$H!"K!N'$GDj$a$i$l$F$$$k!#$?$H$($PC^GHBg3X!"?@8MBg3X!"(B
$B6e=#Bg3X$NM};v$O(B8$BL>!"KL3$F;Bg3X$dEl5~Bg3X$O(B7$BL>$@!#9-EgBg3X$d(B
$B2,;3Bg3X$`(B7$BL>$G$"$k0lJ}$G!"$*Cc$N?e=w;RBg$d0l66Bg3X$O(B4 $BL>$G(B
$B$"$k!#(B

  $B0lBNA4BN!"$3$N?t$N:,5r$O2?$+!#$=$b$=$bK!N'$G@/I\$,M};v$N?t(B
$B$r7h$a$kI,MW$J$I$J$$!#Bg3X<+?H$,7h$a$l$P$h$$$N$@!#$K$b(B $B94$o(B
$B$i$:!"K!N'$G?t$r7h$a$k$N$OE72<$j@h$N%]%9%H3MF@$,L\E*$N0l$D$H(B
$B$7$+;W$($J$$!#(B

  $B:rG/EYFHN)9T@/K!?M$K0\9T$7$?(B9$B>JD#(B57$BK!?M$rNc$K$H$k$H!"FHK!(B
$B2=0JA0$O(B90$B$@$C$?;XDj?&!JM};v!K$N?t$,FHK!2=0J9_$O(B264$BL>$G!"o6PM};v$O(Bl45$BL>!"$=$N(B97% 140$BL>$,41N==P?H$G!"8+(B
$B;v$KE72<$j@h$,A}$($?$N$@!#MW$9$k5kM?$OG/4V(B28$B2/(B9900$BK|1_$G$"$k!#(B

  $B!VBg3X$X$N$3$N$h$&$JG{$j$OF|K\$K$+$D$FB8:_$7$?$3$H$,$J$/!"(B
$BL^O@8=9T@)EY$K$b$J$$!W$H$$$&NkLZ5D0w$NHcH=$K!"1s;3Bg?C$OEzJ[(B
$B$7$?!#(B

  $B!VBg3X$N<+